Water savings project equates to more than $20,000 a megalitre

A think tank has questioned the cost benefits of Murrumbidgee Irrigation’s latest water-saving project and says plans for a surge reservoir are simply “a new dam”.

Key points:

  • The Murrumbidgee Irrigation project is forecast to recover 6.3GL for the environment
  • The Australia Institute says the federal government is paying more than $20,000 for every megalitre recovered
  • It says the proposed “surge reservoir” is “a new dam”

Earlier this week the federal government announced $126 million in funding for the irrigation company to undertake efficiency works to halve its water losses and save 7.4 gigalitres of water.

The money from the $1.54 billion Off-Farm Efficiency Program is to be used to help achieve a 450GL water recovery target under the Murray-Darling Basin Plan without causing negative socio-economic impacts.

Murrumbidgee Irrigation said the $126 million will be spent on finalising automation works, reconstructing open channels and creating a “surge reservoir”.

Of the 7.4GL in water savings, close to 6.3GL will be recovered for the environment and 1.1GL will be retained by Murrumbidgee Irrigation.

Plan’s most expensive recovered water

Think tank The Australia Institute wrote a submission on the project, arguing it would be some of the most expensive water recovered under the Basin Plan to date.

Co-author of the submission Kate McBride said the government would be paying more than $20,000 for every megalitre recovered.

“They’re actually going to use 8 per cent of the funding to recover just 1.4 per cent of the water required under this Water for Environment Special Account,” Ms McBride said.

Kate McBride

Kate McBride says the water saved through the project will be some of the most expensive water recovered under the Basin Plan. (Supplied)

In response to the concerns, a spokesperson from the NSW Department of Planning and Environment said water prices were significantly higher in the current water market than in previous project funding programs. 

“The Australia Institute’s submission’s dollar per megalitre calculation does not consider the additional benefits of investment for the local community through the project,” the spokesperson said.

Murrumbidgee Irrigation chief executive Brett Jones said many of the easier, less-expensive options for recovering water had been completed.

“But in principle, I think the key thing is the investment in infrastructure which is a win for the environment … it’s a win for irrigators … and it’s a win for the community.”

How much water will a surge reservoir save?

Part of the project is to build a 5,000ML surge reservoir which is proposed to save 256ML, just under 4 per cent of the total water savings.

Ms McBride questioned whether funding designed to recover water from the environment should be spent on building “a new dam”.

An irrigation channel flows away from camera into the distance.

Brett Jones says the proposed surge reservoir will reduce water losses when irrigators turn off high flows.(ABC: Anna Vidot)

Mr Jones said the surge reservoir would allow the company to deliver water more efficiently by reducing water losses that would usually occur when irrigators turn off high flows.

“By having these surge reservoirs, as soon as an outlet closes you can divert water into the reservoir,” Mr Jones said.

“It’s not a dam, it’s a 5,000ML, small reservoir.”

The spokesperson from the Department of Planning and Environment said the reservoir would also have socio-economic benefits.

“The reservoir will ensure water is available for crops when required and increase water security for the community and business particularly during drought,” they said.

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
Olympia 2022 Skispringen: Disqualifikationen um Katharina Althaus sorgen für Empörung thumbnail

Olympia 2022 Skispringen: Disqualifikationen um Katharina Althaus sorgen für Empörung

Katharina Althaus im Mixed-Wettbewerb Foto: Lars Baron / Getty Images Eine Disqualifikation von Katharina Althaus hat Dauer-Weltmeister Deutschland bei der Olympia-Premiere des Mixed-Wettbewerbs um die erhoffte Medaille gebracht. Für Silbermedaillengewinnerin Althaus, Karl Geiger, Selina Freitag und Constantin Schmid war wegen des nicht regelkonformen Anzugs der Oberstdorferin somit schon nach dem ersten Durchgang Schluss. »Das ist echt…
Read More
Roma-Juve: the decline of Mou and Allegri, two teams without identity thumbnail

Roma-Juve: the decline of Mou and Allegri, two teams without identity

Un pareggio sarebbe la soluzione peggiore perché affosserebbe sia Mourinho che Allegri. Sul piano tecnico-tattico Roma e Juve condividono un percorso sbagliato. Allineano giocatori senza la connessione del gioco, non c’è un’identità forte che le renda riconoscibili. Tra le parate di Rui Patricio e i gol di Abraham, si notano chiazze desertiche. A Mourinho non…
Read More
Carnaval em casa thumbnail

Carnaval em casa

Em mais um ano de pandemia e com restrições por decretos do Estado e município, determinando e orientando a população, bem como aos estabelecimentos, especialmente de eventos públicos, quanto ao período de carnaval, a Polícia Militar já tem seu planejamento pronto para agir e dá dicas de segurança, mesmo sem a festa popular nas vias…
Read More
Why there's NO WAY Holly Willoughby will be forced out of ITV thumbnail

Why there’s NO WAY Holly Willoughby will be forced out of ITV

Holly Willoughby is flying home from a holiday in Portugal this weekend ahead of her return to the This Morning sofa on Monday.But despite being 'saddened' by Phillip Schofield's suffering, friends say she still hasn't been in touch with her former co-star.The presenter is said to be 'gobsmacked' by her former colleague lifting the lid
Read More
Changing land pricing to cut cost of HDB flats risks destabilising entire property market: DPM Wong, Singapore News thumbnail

Changing land pricing to cut cost of HDB flats risks destabilising entire property market: DPM Wong, Singapore News

SINGAPORE — Changing the way that land is priced to lower the cost of Housing Board flats will risk destabilising the entire property market, said Deputy Prime Minister Lawrence Wong. He cautioned against artificially resetting the housing market in this manner. Wong was responding on Friday (Feb 24) to proposals and concerns raised by MPs over
Read More
Index Of News
Consider making some contribution to keep us going. We are donation based team who works to bring the best content to the readers. Every donation matters.
Donate Now

Subscription Form

Liking our Index Of News so far? Would you like to subscribe to receive news updates daily?

Total
0
Share