We might be in a simulation. How much should that worry us?

By Farhad Manjoo

Imagine that when your great-grandparents were teenagers, they got their hands on a groundbreaking new gadget, the world’s first fully immersive virtual-reality entertainment system. These weren’t those silly goggles you see everywhere now.

This device was more Matrix-y — a stylish headband stuffed with electrodes that somehow tapped directly into the human brain’s perceptual system, replacing whatever a wearer saw, heard, felt, smelled and even tasted with new sensations ginned up by a machine.

The device was a blockbuster; magic headbands soon became an inescapable fact of people’s daily lives. Your great-grandparents, in fact, met each other in Headbandland, and their children, your grandparents, rarely encountered the world outside it. Later generations — your parents, you — never did.

Everything you have ever known, the entire universe you call reality, has been fed to you by a machine.

What is real? The coming world of virtual reality might one day be regarded as every bit as real as real reality.

What is real? The coming world of virtual reality might one day be regarded as every bit as real as real reality.Credit: AP

This, anyway, is the sort of out-there scenario I keep thinking about as I ponder the simulation hypothesis — the idea, lately much discussed among technologists and philosophers, that the world around us could be a digital figment, something like the simulated world of a video game.

The idea is not new. Exploring the underlying nature of reality has been an obsession of philosophers since the time of Socrates and Plato. Ever since “The Matrix,” such notions have become a staple of pop culture, too. But until recently the simulation hypothesis had been a matter for academics. Why should we even consider that technology could create simulations indistinguishable from reality? And even if such a thing were possible, what difference would knowledge of the simulation make to any of us stuck in the here and now, where reality feels all too tragically real?

The coming world of virtual reality might one day be regarded as every bit as real as real reality. If that happens, our current reality will instantly be cast into doubt.

For these reasons, I’ve sat out many of the debates about the simulation hypothesis that have been bubbling through tech communities since the early 2000s, when Nick Bostrom, a philosopher at Oxford, floated the idea in a widely cited essay.

But a brain-bending new book by philosopher David Chalmers — “Reality+: Virtual Worlds and the Problems of Philosophy” — has turned me into a hard-core simulationist.

After reading and talking to Chalmers, I’ve come to believe that the coming world of virtual reality might one day be regarded as every bit as real as real reality. If that happens, our current reality will instantly be cast into doubt; after all, if we could invent meaningful virtual worlds, isn’t it plausible that some other civilisation somewhere else in the universe might have done so, too? Yet if that’s possible, how could we know that we’re not already in its simulation?

Loading

The conclusion seems inescapable: We may not be able to prove that we are in a simulation, but at the very least, it will be a possibility that we can’t rule out.

But it could be more than that. Chalmers argues that if we’re in a simulation, there’d be no reason to think it’s the only simulation; in the same way that lots of different computers today are running Microsoft Excel, lots of different machines might be running an instance of the simulation. If that was the case, simulated worlds would vastly outnumber nonsim worlds — meaning that, just as a matter of statistics, it would be not just possible that our world is one of the many simulations but likely. Chalmers writes that “the chance we are sims is at least 25 per cent or so.”

Chalmers is a professor of philosophy at New York University, and he has spent much of his career thinking about the mystery of consciousness. He is best known for coining the phrase “the hard problem of consciousness,” which, roughly, is a description of the difficulty of explaining why a certain experience feels like that experience to the being experiencing it. (Don’t worry if this hurts your head; it’s not called the hard problem for nothing.)

Chalmers says that he began thinking deeply about the nature of simulated reality after using VR headsets like Oculus Quest 2 and realising that the technology is already good enough to create situations that feel viscerally real.

Keanu Reeves in 2003’s Matrix Reloaded: In the movie franchise, humanity is unknowingly trapped inside a simulated reality, the Matrix, which machines have programmed.

Keanu Reeves in 2003’s Matrix Reloaded: In the movie franchise, humanity is unknowingly trapped inside a simulated reality, the Matrix, which machines have programmed.Credit: AP

Virtual reality is now advancing so quickly that it seems quite reasonable to guess that the world inside VR could one day be indistinguishable from the world outside it. Chalmers says this could happen within a century; I wouldn’t be surprised if we passed that mark within a few decades.

Whenever it happens, the development of realistic VR will be earthshaking, for reasons both practical and profound. The practical ones are obvious: If people can easily flit between the physical world and virtual ones that feel exactly like the physical world, which one should we regard as real?

You might say the answer is clearly the physical one. But why? Today, what happens on the internet doesn’t stay on the internet; the digital world is so deeply embedded in our lives that its effects ricochet across society. After many of us have spent much of the pandemic working and socialising online, it would be foolish to say that life on the internet isn’t real.

The same would hold for VR. Chalmers’ book — which travels entertainingly across ancient Chinese and Indian philosophy to René Descartes to modern theorists like Bostrom and the Wachowskis (the siblings who created “The Matrix”) — is a work of philosophy, and so naturally he goes through a multipart exploration into how physical reality differs from virtual reality.

Virtual reality is now advancing so quickly that it seems quite reasonable to guess that the world inside VR could one day be indistinguishable from the world outside it.

His upshot is this: “Virtual reality isn’t the same as ordinary physical reality,” but because its effects on the world are not fundamentally different from those of physical reality, “it’s a genuine reality all the same.” Thus we should not regard virtual worlds as mere escapist illusions; what happens in VR “really happens,” Chalmers says, and when it’s real enough, people will be able to have “fully meaningful” lives in VR.

To me, this seems self-evident. We already have quite a bit of evidence that people can construct sophisticated realities from experiences they have over a screen-based internet. Why wouldn’t that be the case for an immersive internet?

This gets to what’s profound and disturbing about the coming of VR. The mingling of physical and digital reality has already thrown society into an epistemological crisis — a situation where different people believe different versions of reality based on the digital communities in which they congregate.

Loading

How would we deal with this situation in a far more realistic digital world? Could the physical world even continue to function in a society where everyone has one or several virtual alter egos?

I don’t know. I don’t have a lot of hope that this will go smoothly. But the frightening possibilities suggest the importance of seemingly abstract inquiries into the nature of reality under VR. We should start thinking seriously about the possible effects of virtual worlds now, long before they become too real for comfort.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

Most Viewed in Technology

Loading

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
Norwegian salmon on the run threaten Swedish wild salmon thumbnail

Norwegian salmon on the run threaten Swedish wild salmon

Atlantlax 20 december, 2021 Artikel från SLU Ämne: Miljö & klimat, Natur & teknik Norsk odlad lax rymmer från nätkassar i havet, vandrar upp i västsvenska vattendrag och parar sig med lokal vild lax. Det ställer till problem i det svenska laxbeståndet, då barn till kassodlad lax som föds och växer upp i naturen har…
Read More
ANA's A380 tours Okinawa and Amami to commemorate World Heritage registration thumbnail

ANA's A380 tours Okinawa and Amami to commemorate World Heritage registration

By Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA  全日本空輸(ANA/NH)は9月25日、総2階建ての超大型機エアバスA380型機「FLYING HONU(フライング・ホヌ)」の初号機(登録記号JA381A)による那覇空港発着の遊覧飛行を実施した。約1時間半のフライトで、ユネスコ(国連教育科学文化機関)の世界自然遺産に登録が決まった鹿児島県の奄美大島と徳之島、沖縄島北部と西表島の4地域上空を巡った。 那覇空港を離陸するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire  「空飛ぶウミガメ」を意味するFLYING HONUは、2泊3日のチャーターで24日に成田から那覇へ到着。25日の遊覧飛行の参加者は、成田からのフライトとは別に募った。  遊覧飛行の便名はこれまでと同じNH2030便で、乗客253人(幼児3人含む)と乗員21人(パイロット2人、客室乗務員19人)を乗せ、那覇空港の100番スポットを午後1時10分に出発し第2滑走路(RWY36L)を同52分に離陸。高度約2万1000フィート(約6400メートル)で沖永良部島から徳之島を経て奄美大島へ飛行し、奄美空港の手前で折り返して徳之島、沖永良部島、久米島の上空を巡り、那覇空港の第2滑走路(RWY36L)に午後3時21分に着陸し、同30分に100番スポットへ戻った。  ANAのA380の座席数は4クラス520席で、ファーストクラスが8席、ビジネスクラスが56席、プレミアムエコノミーが73席、エコノミーが383席。遊覧飛行の旅行代金は、ファーストクラスが7万9800円、ビジネスクラス窓側が4万9800円、同通路側が3万9800円、プレミアムエコノミー窓側が3万9800円、同通路側が2万9800円、エコノミークラス窓側2万9800円、同窓側翼上が2万2800円、同通路側が1万4800円だった。  成田-那覇チャーターの復路は、26日午後3時ごろ那覇を出発し、成田には午後5時50分ごろ到着する見通し。 *写真は19枚。 *那覇到着の記事はこちら。那覇空港で出発を待つANAのA380初号機=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港を出発するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港を出発するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便(下)と離陸する航空自衛隊のF-15=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire ANAグループ社員に見送られて那覇空港を出発するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港を出発するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港の第2滑走路へ向かうANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港の第2滑走路へ向かうANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation Wire 那覇空港を離陸するANAのA380初号機による遊覧飛行のNH2030便=21年9月25日 PHOTO: Tadayuki YOSHIKAWA/Aviation…
Read More
Avoid Crowds at Popular Destinations to Try These Hidden Gems thumbnail

Avoid Crowds at Popular Destinations to Try These Hidden Gems

TravelLjubljana instead of Venice, Raja Ampat instead of Bali: these less visited places are just as charming as their more popular counterparts.Published January 5, 202411 min readIn 2023, travel came back with a vengeance, with travel bookings climbing to near pre-COVID-19 numbers, according to a recent Prosper Insights & Analytics survey. But many destinations struggled
Read More
Not Dead Yet: Skype Gets a Redesign in 2021 thumbnail

Not Dead Yet: Skype Gets a Redesign in 2021

MicrosoftMicrosoft is clearly trying to get people to use Teams. However, that doesn’t mean the company has completely forgotten about Skype. The company just put out a redesign for Skype that adds a fresh new look and some interesting features. What’s New With Skype? Microsoft describes the latest of many Skype redesigns as an “improved,…
Read More
A 'chemical cocktail' of sewage, slurry and plastic is polluting English rivers thumbnail

A ‘chemical cocktail’ of sewage, slurry and plastic is polluting English rivers

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Poor water quality in English rivers is the result of chronic underinvestment and multiple failures in monitoring, governance and enforcement, a report from the UK Parliament's Environmental Audit Committee has claimed. The report includes evidence from The University of Manchester's Professor Jamie Woodward, whose research demonstrated a direct link between poor…
Read More
Index Of News
Consider making some contribution to keep us going. We are donation based team who works to bring the best content to the readers. Every donation matters.
Donate Now

Subscription Form

Liking our Index Of News so far? Would you like to subscribe to receive news updates daily?

Total
0
Share