Win for Collaery derails Porter’s attempt to cover up Timor-Leste bugging

In a defeat for the federal government in its pursuit of Bernard Collaery, the attempt by former attorney-general Christian Porter to keep the trial hidden has been overturned by the ACT court of appeal.

Lawyer Bernard Collaery (Image: AAP/Lukas Coch)
In a significant defeat for the federal government and former attorney-general Christian Porter, the Supreme Court of the ACT has overturned secrecy orders demanded by Porter in his prosecution of Bernard Collaery, which would have ensured much of the trial was conducted in complete secrecy and evidence would have been hidden not merely from the public but from Collaery and his lawyers.Judges Murrell, Burns and Wigney overturned trial Judge David Mossop’s decision to grant Porter’s application to hide evidence against Collaery, and witness evidence produced by Collaery, via national security orders made by Porter under the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004. The appellate court ruled that

public disclosure of information relating to the truth of the identified matters would involve a risk of prejudice to national security. However, the court doubted that a significant risk of prejudice to national security would materialise. On the other hand, there was a very real risk of damage to public confidence in the administration of justice if the evidence could not be publicly disclosed. The court emphasised that the open hearing of criminal trials was important because it deterred political prosecutions, allowed the public to scrutinise the actions of prosecutors, and permitted the public to properly assess the conduct of the accused person.

The ruling threatens to derail the entire trial of Collaery for conspiracy and revealing information because the government is desperate to keep embarrassing details of the actions of the Howard government, and the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, out of the public eye. Under John Howard and Alexander Downer, the Australian Secret Intelligence Service illegally bugged the Timor-Leste cabinet room in an effort to secure an advantage in negotiations with the fledgling state over access to resources under the Timor Sea.Downer and the then-head of DFAT Ashton Calvert later took positions with a major beneficiary of the deal, Woodside.If details of those events are made public, the Coalition will face embarrassment and further questions about its vexatious pursuit of Collaery and Witness K, a former ASIS officer who in June was given a three month suspended sentence for his role in the revelation of the bugging, which he did so as part of a workplace dispute with ASIS.It is expected that current Attorney-General Michaelia Cash — who has her own links to the issue via her previous employment with major law firm Freehills, which worked with ConocoPhillips on Timor Gap matters — will appeal the ruling. Crikey understands that there is intense resentment toward Collaery within the federal Coalition and a determination to pursue him to the fullest extent possible for his revelation of the crimes of the Howard government.

Crikey

It’s time to book your next dose of Crikey.

Through the week, news comes at you fast. Every day there’s a new disaster, depressing numbers or a scandal to doom-scroll to. It’s exhausting, and not good for your health.Book your next dose of Crikey to get on top of it all. Subscribe now and get your first 12 weeks for $12. And you’ll help us too, because every dollar we get helps us dig even deeper.

Peter FrayPeter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey

12 weeks for just $12.

About the Author

Bernard KeanePolitics Editor @BernardKeaneBernard Keane is Crikey’s political editor. Before that he was Crikey’s Canberra press gallery correspondent, covering politics, national security and economics.

Bernard Keane — Politics Editor

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
「全員がコロナにかかる。感染せずに一生を終えることは困難」感染症の米専門医が持論 オミクロンが最後の変異株には…:中日スポーツ・東京中日スポーツ thumbnail

「全員がコロナにかかる。感染せずに一生を終えることは困難」感染症の米専門医が持論 オミクロンが最後の変異株には…:中日スポーツ・東京中日スポーツ

新型コロナウイルスの変異株「オミクロン株」(国立感染症研究所提供)  米ニューヨーク州、ロチェスター総合病院の感染症部長、エド・ウォルシュ医師は、いずれはコロナに感染せずに一生を終えることは、ほぼ不可能になるとの持論を展開した。27日の米放送局WHAMが報じた。  「時間がたてば、さらに多くの新型コロナウイルス変異株が出現し、さらに多くの人々が感染するだろう。私の予測では、いずれそのうち、われわれ全員が何らかのコロナ変異株にかかる」。その理由として、同医師は「ワクチンはいかなる感染に対しても、100%の予防にはならないからだ。感染せずに一生を終えることは困難を極めるだろう。というのも、このウイルスはいずれ(地域に根差した)風土病になるからだ。そのまま消えてしまうことにはならない」と説明した。  同病院のエミル・リーショー感染症専門医も、オミクロンが最後の変異株になってほしいとの希望について「それはほぼあり得ない。オミクロンが最後の変異株になるだろうという誤った安心感を受け入れることはできない」と同調した。  実際、米国ではパンデミックから2年弱で、全人口の約22%に相当する約7300万人が感染し、約88万人が死亡。濃厚接触者にいたっては、人口の9割にのぼるとされる。  現在、世界で感染の主流となっているのはオミクロン株だが、これの亜種、通称“ステルス・オミクロン株”が増加しつつある。デンマークやフィリピンなどでは、既に新規感染の半分以上が従来のオミクロン株に取って代わったと報じられ、感染力も従来の株より強いとの研究報告例がある。 購読試読のご案内 プロ野球はもとより、メジャーリーグ、サッカー、格闘技のほかF1をはじめとするモータースポーツ情報がとくに充実。芸能情報や社会面ニュースにも定評あり。
Read More
Microvascular Therapeutics Welcomes Thom Tulip as Chief Business Officer thumbnail

Microvascular Therapeutics Welcomes Thom Tulip as Chief Business Officer

Tucson, AZ, February 10, 2024 --(PR.com)-- Microvascular Therapeutics Inc. (MVT), a clinical-stage biotech company at the forefront of developing the next generation of microbubbles unlocking the therapeutic potential of ultrasound, proudly announces the appointment of Dr Thom Tulip as their new Chief Business Officer. In this pivotal role, Dr Tulip will lead capital raises to propel
Read More
The Biden administration has ’emboldened China’ thumbnail

The Biden administration has ’emboldened China’

Former US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo says China feels emboldened to harass journalists because the Biden administration is not “putting America first” when it comes to foreign policy.The comments come after the Chinese Communist Party were condemned after a security officer interrupted a Dutch reporter in the middle of a live broadcast.
Read More

“Putin forged elections”

סגנו של מנהיג האופוזיציה הרוסית אלכסיי נבלני, לאוניד וולקוב, בראיון: "המשטר עשה שימוש בכל אמצעי פסול" • ועל העתיד: "שלטון פוטין לא יוחלף בבחירות" • מחר ב"ישראל השבוע"
Read More
Index Of News
Consider making some contribution to keep us going. We are donation based team who works to bring the best content to the readers. Every donation matters.
Donate Now

Subscription Form

Liking our Index Of News so far? Would you like to subscribe to receive news updates daily?

Total
0
Share