Clarence Thomas wants to topple a precedent that helps Fox News

The legal standard at the heart of Dominion’s defamation suit against Fox News is the “actual malice” test from a landmark Supreme Court case, New York Times Company v. Sullivan. Ironically, Justice Clarence Thomaswhose views seemingly align with Fox News, has spoken out against the 1964 precedent that currently makes it harder for plaintiffs like Dominion to sue.

As I’ve noted on the blogthe actual malice standard requires public figures alleging defamation to show that defendants knew or recklessly disregarded the truth. It’s a tough test to meet, and what makes Dominion’s case unusual is the extent of evidence it claims can help it meet that tough standard.

Thomas, meanwhile, has called on his colleagues to revisit the precedent (sound familiar?). In June, he lamented in dissent that the Times v. Sullivan decision has “allowed media organizations and interest groups ‘to cast false aspersions on public figures with near impunity.’” Thomas’ dissent was prompted by the court declining to hear a case that seemingly aligned with his ideological sympathies, brought by a Christian nonprofit organization that was deemed an anti-LGBT hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center. Thomas complained that the plaintiff was “unable to satisfy the ‘almost impossible’ actual-malice standard this Court has imposed.”

“Public figure or private, lies impose real harm,” Thomas wrote in dissent of the court’s refusal to hear another case in 2021. Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote his own dissent in that same case, also raising the prospect of revisiting the defamation precedent. Of course, Thomas wasn’t talking about Fox News and 2020 election lies when he wrote about lies imposing real harm, but the notion applies just as well to the allegations in Dominion’s suit.

Yet, if Thomas’ view were to become law, whatever harm or benefit that would bring, in a case like Dominion’s, it could put Fox News in even greater danger of defamation liability than it already is.

Jordan Rubin

Jordan Rubin is the Deadline: Legal Blog writer. He was a prosecutor for the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office and is the author of the forthcoming book “Bizarro” about the secret war on synthetic drugs. Before he joined MSNBC, he was a legal reporter for Bloomberg Law.

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
Customised kicks: North Macedonia sneaker artist sketches new path thumbnail

Customised kicks: North Macedonia sneaker artist sketches new path

SKOPJE - From a makeshift studio in a cramped apartment in North Macedonia's Skopje, Satja Grabuloski has made his mark as one of the top sneaker artists in the world.   With more than 300 celebrities as customers, Grabuloski has taken orders from famous athletes, actors, and musicians -- including Lebron James and Dua Lipa. Using
Read More
First China Int'l Supply Chain Expo to be held in Beijing thumbnail

First China Int’l Supply Chain Expo to be held in Beijing

This photo taken on Nov. 26, 2023 shows the booth of the China Resources Pharmaceutical Commercial Group Co., Ltd. at the China International Supply Chain Expo (CISCE) in Beijing, capital of China. The first CISCE will be held from Nov. 28 to Dec. 2 in Beijing. (Xinhua/Ren Chao)This photo taken on Nov. 26, 2023 shows
Read More
Oligarchs See at Least $156M in Property, Yachts Seized in Italy thumbnail

Oligarchs See at Least $156M in Property, Yachts Seized in Italy

Authorities in Italy have seized property belonging to five Russian oligarchs who were placed on the European Union's sanctions list following Russia's invasion of Ukraine.The property includes villas and yachts valued around $156 million, according to Reuters, which reported on Saturday. Reuters also noted that properties owned by billionaire Alisher Usmanov, Russian state TV host…
Read More
“You Obidients Are Busy Cursing Me. Me I Am Busy Cashing Out Of You” thumbnail

“You Obidients Are Busy Cursing Me. Me I Am Busy Cashing Out Of You”

Nigerian Author and Social Media Critic, Reno Omokri claim that he is making money out of criticism, curses, and support due to different opinions on presidential candidates. Reno Omokri, 49 chieftains of the Peoples Democratic Party has been dragged since the beginning of the campaign for supporting and giving reasons why Nigerians should vote for
Read More
Index Of News
Total
0
Share