An exercise in fragmentation: Limiting Android installs to device models

As if there were not enough fragmentation issues with Android, app makers go out and make it worse when they limit installations to specific devices.

Here I sit, with a barely six-month-old Galaxy S4, and yet I cannot use an app available for the device, because the version of the S4 that I have is the S4 Active, Samsung’s latest waterproof phone.It’s one of the grating issues I have with using an Android device. Despite all of the good work that Google has done to subdue the problems that developers encounter with fragmentation, a certain type of device and app maker is determined to divide and conquer Android, a handful of devices at a time.In the past two days, a pair of apps with device restrictions have appeared in the Play Store: The long-awaited Android version of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s iView app, and Foxtel’s Go app. What is simultaneously interesting and frustrating is that rather than restricting the deployment of the apps by Android version number or screen resolution, both have taken the path of only allowing certain devices to install it with the use of a whitelist.For why this is an issue, just look at the lovely list of devices in the Play Developer Console that appear when a search for “S4” is conducted.


The problems kick into gear when you realise that Samsung treats “S4” as both a device name and an overall term for a collection of devices. Not only does the company make a “Samsung Galaxy S4”, but it also sells a “Samsung Galaxy S4 Active”, “Samsung Galaxy S4 Zoom”, “Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini”, “Samsung Galaxy S4 Google Play Edition”, and a “Samsung Galaxy S4 Duo”, as well as having a motley collection of model numbers.So when an app maker says its app is supported on the Galaxy S4, maybe it is, and maybe it isn’t. In the case of the ABC app, after an initial refusal, about an hour later, the app was allowed to be installed on my S4. As for the Foxtel app, despite having all the performance and other requirements to run the app, I was refused by Foxtel’s device whitelisting.Upon asking why it allows one S4 model and not another, Foxtel responded by saying, “each Android device behaves differently and needs to be checked to ensure it provides the right Foxtel experience and that content is delivered securely”.Despite the app having Samsung exclusivity, the company said it would “love to get Foxtel Go on as many devices as possible and are working hard to do so”.Making decisions on app availability based on phone models is not the right way to go about Android app development, and does nothing to help the Android ecosystem.What is the point of having a homogeneous platform span across many different devices if apps are going to ignore suitable devices that are capable of using them?It would make little sense in the PC world to restrict an app to only Lenovos or HP computers, and it makes just as little sense in the mobile world.

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
Paying at the charging station is made unnecessarily difficult for customers thumbnail

Paying at the charging station is made unnecessarily difficult for customers

Wie soll man an den Ladesäulen bezahlen? Ohne App geht gar nichts. Nun streiten alle Beteiligten, welche zusätzlichen Bezahlfunktionen die Ladesäulen haben müssen. Betreiber und Bundesregierung streiten über die Bezahlmöglichkeiten an den Ladesäulen. Getty Images / picture alliance Der Ausbau der Elektromobilität ist bisher recht erfolgreich verlaufen und weiter im vollen Gange. Wäre da nicht…
Read More
LibreOffice 7.3.0 thumbnail

LibreOffice 7.3.0

HOME · HARDWARE · VIDEOGIOCHI · SOFTWARE · DOWNLOAD · BUSINESS · FOTOGRAFIA · VIDEO · APPUNTI DIGITALI · FORUM · HWMEDIAGROUP Passa alla versioneDesktop | Mobile © 1997 - 2022 - Hardware Upgrade S.r.l. P.iva: 02560740124 Hardware Upgrade, testata giornalistica con registrazione tribunale di Varese, n. 879 del 30/07/2005. Iscrizione ROC n. 13366 -…
Read More
Climate change: COP26 conference hailed as 'world's best last chance.' Here's why thumbnail

Climate change: COP26 conference hailed as ‘world’s best last chance.’ Here’s why

The planet, you've likely heard, isn't doing so well. The latest report from the United Nations' chief climate body, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, shows global temperatures are very likely to rise 1.5 degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels in the next few decades. Human-generated greenhouse gas emissions are unequivocally the cause. Increasing temperatures, scientists have shown,…
Read More
Index Of News
Consider making some contribution to keep us going. We are donation based team who works to bring the best content to the readers. Every donation matters.
Donate Now

Subscription Form

Liking our Index Of News so far? Would you like to subscribe to receive news updates daily?