COVID Vax Exemptions for Pregnant Healthcare Workers?

Hospitals have had to reckon with decisions over whether or not to provide COVID-19 vaccine exemptions — or temporary deferrals — to pregnant employees.

Those decisions, which continue to be polarizing for many pregnant women in the workforce, have to be made at a time when guidelines, legislation, and healthcare staffing demands can all be at odds.

New York State has led the charge in requiring COVID-19 vaccines for all healthcare workers. In a guidance letter to state healthcare facilities on August 23, New York State Health Commissioner Howard Zucker, MD, JD, wrote that “pregnancy alone is not a valid ‘health condition’ upon which to base a medical exemption.”

In the weeks following the state’s revised restrictions to vaccine exemptions, at least one New York hospital reported being in danger of “pausing” certain clinical services due to staffing shortages caused by healthcare workers’ refusal to get vaccinated.

Outside of New York, though, many hospitals continue to hold pregnancy exemptions in place for employees until further notice. They are left to navigate available legislation, CDC recommendations urging pregnant people and those hoping to get pregnant to get the COVID-19 vaccine, the local threat of the pandemic, and a potential worsening of their staffing shortages.

The Biden administration has yet to issue more specifics on where pregnancy fits into the list of medical exemptions. Employers must follow current law, which, according to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and Title VII as amended by the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, asserts that pregnant workers must be “treated the same as others who are similar in their ability or inability to work.”

At the same time, the EEOC also states that “employees who are not vaccinated because of pregnancy may be entitled (under Title VII) to adjustments to keep working, if the employer makes modifications or exceptions for other employees.”

Right now, hospitals are required to provide employees with the option to seek vaccine exemptions if they are experiencing a pregnancy-related medical condition or disability, just like any other employee who has a medical condition or disability. Yet some hospitals, despite opposing legal perspectives, have decided that pregnancy itself counts as an eligible medical reason to avert or postpone vaccination.

At Yale Medicine, and with the approval of their physician, healthcare workers at various stages of pregnancy are eligible to defer the COVID-19 vaccine. Infectious disease and pediatrics expert Richard Martinello, MD, of Yale Medicine, told MedPage Today that, beyond those who are currently pregnant, people trying to get pregnant and those who are breastfeeding have the option to seek deferment.

Less than 1% of Yale Medicine healthcare workers are seeking exemptions under this policy, Martinello said. In Connecticut, he noted, vaccine hesitancy isn’t nearly as strong as it is in other parts of the country.

“We’re pretty comfortable with where we are and we’re going to sit tight with our current policies,” Martinello said of their pregnancy exemption rules. “We do continually try to ensure that our physicians and physicians in the community are aware of what the latest guidelines are, so that’s part of our active discussion.”

Yale Medicine’s vaccination deadline is September 30. After that, those who are exempt are required to get tested weekly; getting a test at one of Yale Medicine’s COVID-19 testing sites is free for staff regardless of vaccination status, Martinello added.

Michael Leonardi, MD, a maternal and fetal medicine physician who specializes in high-risk pregnancies at OSF Healthcare in Illinois, echoed the notion that concerns about staffing shortages likely have an influence over exemption policies.

“Healthcare systems don’t exist in a vacuum, and prior to the federal mandate, they’ve got to staff their hospitals,” Leonardi told MedPage Today. “So if they are short-staffed already, that influences how strongly they can push their staff. If you’re in an area that has a lot of vaccine hesitancy, you’re going to have a steeper hill to climb than if you’re in an area like Vermont that has embraced vaccination.”

At OSF, an employee may still seek exemption due to pregnancy. Those looking to get pregnant, however, cannot, according to Leonardi. Unlike other hospital systems, which may allow employees to use individual physician approval to apply for vaccine exemption, a pregnant healthcare worker at OSF seeking exemption from the COVID-19 vaccine may only do so through the Occupational Safety and Health Administration.

“I think that was smart because it avoids physicians injecting their own bias into it, or being willing to write notes for patients without making any effort to counsel them about ACOG and AAP [American Academy of Pediatrics] and CDC recommendations,” Leonardi said.

Leonardi, who hopes that OSF’s pregnancy exemption policies can change to follow a stricter model such as New York’s, added that, at OSF, those who get a deferral are logistically and financially responsible for their required weekly COVID-19 testing.

On the department level, members of hospital staff are finding their own ways not to aid employees seeking exemption due to pregnancy.

“As a department, we’ve decided that we’re not going to provide exemptions,” said Darla Berry, MSN, CNM, head of the nurse-midwife team at Indiana University’s School of Medicine. “We can provide documentation that you are pregnant, and then what the institution decides to do with that is up to them.”

Berry noted that her department right now is seeing an unprecedented number of COVID-positive pregnant patients. Caring for otherwise healthy women who have had to be put on ventilators and deliver their babies extremely preterm due to COVID, has possibly contributed to her staff’s willingness to get vaccinated despite their own pregnancy status.

“We have women who are delivering babies and then being put on transplant lists for lungs because their disease has become so severe,” Berry said. “So if the science and organizational recommendation is not enough, then maybe seeing what it can do would be enough of a motivator to help people make that decision,” Berry told MedPage Today.

When it comes to the topic of losing staff members due to stricter exemption policies, Berry has a different view.

“The one thing that would really impact and preserve staffing levels would be increasing vaccination rates,” Berry said. “If you increase vaccination rates, then you would decrease hospitalizations with severe disease, which would then decrease the strain and the stress on the system and the staff.”

  • author['full_name']

    Kara Grant joined the Enterprise & Investigative Reporting team at MedPage Today in February 2021. She covers psychiatry, mental health, and medical education. Follow

Note: This article have been indexed to our site. We do not claim legitimacy, ownership or copyright of any of the content above. To see the article at original source Click Here

Related Posts
WHO is critical to delivering our health agenda in line with global best practices-Anambra State Governor  thumbnail

WHO is critical to delivering our health agenda in line with global best practices-Anambra State Governor 

The Anambra State Governor, Professor Charles Chukwuma Soludo says, the World Health Organization (WHO) is critical to delivering our mandate to the Anambra people.  Welcoming the WHO Country Representative (WR) Dr Walter Kazadi Mulombo to Government lodge in Awka on 24 June 2022, he said, “No government can make significant progress in health without building…
Read More
바이든 “우크라이나 침공 시 러시아에 재앙 될 것” thumbnail

바이든 “우크라이나 침공 시 러시아에 재앙 될 것”

조 바이든 미국 대통령. 워싱턴=AP뉴시스 미국의 조 바이든 대통령은 러시아가 우크라이나를 침공할 경우 책임을 물을 것이라며 강경 대응을 공언했다. 로이터통신에 따르면 19일(현지시간) 바이든 대통령은 취임 1주년을 하루 앞둔 이날 기자회견을 열고 블라디미르 푸틴 대통령은 자신이 약속한 제재를 결코 본 적이 없었다면서 이같이 말했다. 지금까지와는 다른 초강경 대응을 시사한 대목이다. 바이든 대통령은 러시아가 우크라이나를 침공한다면 러시아에 재앙이…
Read More
Family fun days thumbnail

Family fun days

One lucky reader will win an overnight stay and a trip to the zoo with Mercure Bristol Holland House and Bristol Zoological Society. At the Wild Place Project, you’ll discover lots of outdoor Play Wild areas, including Congo Bongo, a Giant Bird’s Nest and Bear Wood, as well as Barefoot Trail where you can throw
Read More
Meat-Heavy Diets Might Have Link to MS thumbnail

Meat-Heavy Diets Might Have Link to MS

By Robert PreidtHealthDay ReporterTUESDAY, Feb. 1, 2022 (HealthDay News) -- If you eat a lot of meat, you may be at increased risk for multiple sclerosis (MS), a new study suggests.MS is an autoimmune disease in which the body attacks the insulation around nerves. It's not clear what triggers the attack, but mounting evidence suggests…
Read More
Allied Health Professionals Fill the Gaps in Healthcare Settings thumbnail

Allied Health Professionals Fill the Gaps in Healthcare Settings

In the past 12 months, 96% of healthcare facilities reported using temporary allied healthcare professionals to supplement their existing staff, based on survey results from 204 facilities. The Survey of Temporary Allied Healthcare Professional Staffing Trends was conducted by AMN Healthcare, a comprehensive healthcare staffing organization that assists hospitals, medical groups, government entities, and other…
Read More
Index Of News
Consider making some contribution to keep us going. We are donation based team who works to bring the best content to the readers. Every donation matters.
Donate Now

Subscription Form

Liking our Index Of News so far? Would you like to subscribe to receive news updates daily?